The rise of Short Term rentals has undeniably reshaped Canada’s accommodation and housing markets over the past decade. Facilitated by online platforms, homeowners found new avenues for income, and travellers gained access to unique lodging options. However, this surge also brought significant challenges, particularly concerning housing affordability, neighbourhood character, and regulatory oversight. Cities and provinces across Canada are now grappling with how to manage the Short Term rentals sector effectively, balancing economic opportunities with community well-being. This evolving landscape presents both challenges and potential shifts in the housing market, impacting renters, homeowners, and prospective buyers alike.
The Growth and Governance of Short Term Rentals in Canada
The initial appeal of Short Term rentals was clear: homeowners could monetize spare rooms or entire properties, while tourists enjoyed alternatives to traditional hotels, often in residential neighbourhoods. This model thrived, especially in tourist hubs and major urban centers. However, the rapid, often unregulated expansion led to growing concerns. Critics argued that lucrative Short Term rentals were incentivizing property owners to remove units from the long-term rental market, exacerbating housing shortages and driving up rents in already expensive cities. Furthermore, issues like noise complaints, security concerns, and the “hollowing out” of residential communities became prominent points of contention.
In response, municipalities began experimenting with regulations. Cities like Vancouver and short term rentals Toronto implemented rules requiring licenses, limiting the types of properties eligible for short-term renting (often restricting it to principal residences), and imposing taxes. These measures aimed to curb the conversion of long-term housing into de facto hotels while still allowing some flexibility for homeowners. The effectiveness and enforcement of these municipal rules varied, leading some provinces to consider broader, more standardized approaches. The landscape for short term rentals Calgary has also seen discussions and regulatory adjustments, reflecting a nationwide trend towards greater oversight of the short term rental market.
Spotlight on BC: A Provincial Crackdown on Short Term Rentals
British Columbia emerged as a focal point in the Canadian debate over Short Term rentals regulation. Facing intense pressure due to soaring housing costs and low vacancy rates, the provincial government introduced significant legislation aimed at returning more units to the long-term market. Taking effect on May 1, 2024, these rules represent one of the most comprehensive provincial interventions in Canada’s short term rental sector.
The core of the B.C. legislation restricts Short Term rentals to a host’s principal residence, plus one secondary suite or laneway home on the same property. This “principal residence requirement” applies to most communities with populations over 10,000, effectively banning the operation of dedicated, non-resident-occupied Short Term rentals in many areas.
Key components of the BC short-term rental enforcement strategy include:
- Principal Residence Requirement: The most significant change, limiting eligibility for short-term renting.
- Provincial Registry: Hosts must register their properties with the province and display their registration number on listings. This registry aims to improve transparency and aid enforcement. Platforms are required to share data with the province.
- Increased Fines: Substantial penalties (up to $5,000 per day for hosts breaking the rules) are designed as a deterrent.
- Platform Accountability: Online platforms face fines if they list non-compliant properties.
- Data Sharing: Platforms must share information with municipalities and the province to help identify illegal operations.
The government’s stated goal was clear: increase the supply of long-term rental housing and improve affordability. Housing Minister Ravi Kahlon positioned the regulations as a necessary step to address the housing crisis, citing early indications of success. He noted a significant number of properties disappearing from Short Term rentals platforms and pointed to anecdotal evidence of former STR units becoming available for long-term tenants.
Assessing the Impact: One Year After BC’s New Rules
With the B.C. regulations now in effect for a year (as of May 2025), the question arises: have they achieved their objectives? The picture is complex, with various data points and expert opinions offering different perspectives.
- Government Perspective & Data: Minister Kahlon declared the policy a success, citing ministry data showing significant drops in entire-home listings on STR platforms between May 2024 and February 2025: Kelowna (-31%), Victoria (-24%), and Vancouver (-22%). The ministry also linked these drops to increases in vacancy rates in these communities between 2023 and 2024. Furthermore, Kahlon highlighted the provincial registry, noting that by early April 2025, around 15,000 properties were registered, compared to an estimated 22,000 listings pre-regulation. This suggests approximately 7,000 operators potentially exited the market or chose not to register. The province also began collecting registration fees, totalling over $3 million by April 2025.
- Market Data & Trends: Market data presents a more nuanced view. Rentals.ca reported a slight year-over-year decrease in average B.C. rent (-0.6%) in March 2025, with a more significant drop in Vancouver (-5.7%). Vancouver’s decline marked the 16th consecutive month of falling apartment rents listed on the site. Similarly, short term rentals Toronto, which also has STR restrictions, saw average listed rents fall 6.9%.
However, not all indicators point downwards. Rent in Victoria was up 3% in March 2025 according to Rentals.ca. Furthermore, the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) forecasted in February 2025 that while B.C.’s vacancy rates might rise due to slowing population growth, average rents would likely increase as new, higher-priced units enter the market. CMHC’s Fall 2024 Rental Market Report also showed average Vancouver rent for a two-bedroom apartment was up 5.5% in October 2024 compared to the previous year, although the rate of increase had slowed.
- Tenant Advocacy View: Will Gladman from the Vancouver Tenants Union reported that their members were generally experiencing rent increases, not decreases. While acknowledging that converting former Short Term rentals back to long-term housing is positive (“Those were units that… were wasted and are now becoming homes”), he argued the impact on overall affordability remains minimal. He viewed the STR regulations as a “supply-side tweak” insufficient to address the systemic affordability crisis when relying primarily on market-based solutions.
The consensus seems to be that while the B.C. regulations have likely shifted some units from the short term rental market to the long-term market, quantifying the precise impact on affordability is difficult due to numerous confounding economic factors. The effect on tourism also remains a significant concern for some stakeholders.
The Homeownership Angle: Navigating Your First Purchase Amidst Market Shifts
The dynamics of the rental market, influenced partly by Short Term rentals regulations, inevitably connect to the broader housing landscape, including homeownership. As rental supply potentially increases in some areas, or as market sentiment shifts, opportunities for first-time homebuyers might evolve. However, entering the market remains a significant financial undertaking. Amidst planning down payments and mortgages, a common question arises for aspiring homeowners: What amount do I claim for first time homebuyer benefits?
In Canada, the federal government offers the Home Buyers’ Amount (HBA), a non-refundable tax credit designed to help with the costs associated with purchasing a first home. For the 2024 tax year (filed in 2025), the amount you can claim for this credit is $10,000. This translates to a federal tax credit of $1,500 ($10,000 x 15% lowest federal income tax rate).
So, how to claim first time homebuyer tax credit?
- Eligibility: You (and your spouse or common-law partner, if applicable) must not have owned and lived in another home in the year of purchase or the preceding four calendar years. The home must be acquired to be your principal place of residence.
- Claiming: You claim the $10,000 amount on Line 31270 of your Schedule 1, Federal Tax return. Even if you co-own the home with others who also qualify, the total claimed across all individuals cannot exceed $10,000 for that home purchase.
- Disability Exception: Special rules apply for individuals eligible for the Disability Tax Credit, potentially allowing them to claim the HBA even if they don’t meet the standard first-time buyer criteria, provided the home is more accessible or better suited to their needs.
While this $1,500 credit is helpful, it’s just one piece of the financial puzzle. Securing the right mortgage, understanding closing costs, and navigating fluctuating market conditions, potentially influenced by factors like Short Term rentals supply shifts, requires careful planning and expert guidance.
The Ongoing Evolution of Short Term Rentals and Housing in Canada
The Canadian experience with Short Term rentals is a dynamic narrative of innovation, economic opportunity, community impact, and regulatory response. The B.C. government’s decisive action represents a significant attempt to rebalance the market in favour of long-term housing, and early indicators suggest it is influencing the number of Short Term rentals operating. However, the complex interplay of interest rates, economic conditions, population movements, and overall housing supply means that attributing changes in affordability solely to these regulations is premature.
Cities like short term rentals Toronto and short term rentals Calgary continue to navigate their own regulatory paths, reflecting the localized nature of housing challenges. The debate highlights fundamental tensions between property rights, tourism economies, and the urgent need for affordable, stable housing for residents. As data continues to emerge and markets adjust, the long-term efficacy and potential unintended consequences of stringent Short Term rentals rules will become clearer. What is certain is that the conversation around how best to integrate or control this sector within Canada’s diverse housing markets is far from over. For individuals navigating this landscape, whether as renters, homeowners, or aspiring buyers asking “how to claim first time homebuyer tax credit”, staying informed and seeking expert advice remains crucial.
Start Your Homeownership Journey with Confidence! Navigating the Canadian mortgage landscape, especially amidst evolving market dynamics influenced by factors like Short Term rentals regulations, requires expertise. Pegasus Mortgage Lending has over 20 years of experience helping thousands of Canadians achieve their homeownership dreams.
